States are jumping on the "science of reading" bandwagon, writes Sarah Schwartz for Education Week. New York, Massachusetts, Indiana, Iowa and Maryland are moving to align instruction to evidence-based methods. That means teaching phonics explicitly rather than telling students to guess words based on pictures or context.
"Over the past decade, 37 states and the District of Columbia have passed laws or other policies related to evidence-based reading instruction," she writes. Mississippi, which started first in 2013 with a comprehensive reform of reading instruction, has seen significant progress.
New York is one of the last states to tackle reading instruction, writes Robert Pondiscio, of the American Enterprise Institute. Gov. Kathy Hochul's "back to basics" plan calls for training teachers in the “science of reading."
The Reading League is “cautiously optimistic” about the plan, he writes, but suggests dropping the "basics" branding, which promotes the "common and unhelpful narrative that the 'science of reading' begins and ends with phonics."
It's a critical step in a journey that includes building students' knowledge and vocabulary.
In addition, the Reading League wants to train teachers before adopting high-quality curriculum.
Pondiscio disagrees. He suggests learning from Louisiana's curriculum-based reforms, pioneered by John White, a former New York City teacher. The Pelican State has "used curriculum adoption to drive changes in classroom practice, providing incentives for their state’s districts and schools to adopt and implement a coherent, high-quality English language arts (ELA) curriculum, then use that curriculum as the hook on which everything else hung: assessment, professional development, and teacher training."
He also recommends the Reading League's Curriculum Evaluation Guidelines.
Missouri is moving to evidence-based reading, writes Kevin Mahnken on The 74. KIPP's six charter schools in St. Louis began retraining teachers and adopting new curricula in 2019.
KIPP Victory showed the strongest reading growth of any elementary school in the state in 2021 standardized testing.
In the next few years, Angela Jackson, who heads elementary literacy instruction, plans to move "all three KIPP elementary schools toward the Core Knowledge Language Arts curriculum, which places a heavy emphasis on the explicit teaching of academic content and the cultivation of students’ subject-matter knowledge," writes Mahnken. "A study released last year showed that schools relying on the Core Knowledge sequence saw large improvements in ELA, math, and science scores."
Oregon's proposed new literacy standards will require teacher colleges to train teachers in evidence-based practices, writes Alex Baumhardt for the Capital Chronicle.
"The revamped standards include an emphasis on directly and comprehensively teaching kids reading skills based on scientific research about how the brain learns written language, and an emphasis on instruction effective for children with disabilities and for those who are learning English as a second or third language," writes Baumhardt.
According to the National Council on Teacher Quality, "nearly all colleges in Oregon are failing to use reading instructional methods known to be most effective for all kids."
Oregon is the only state where reading and math scores show no signs of "learning recovery," according to a Stanford-Harvard analysis.
"Why Johnny Can't Read" was published in 1955. It showed that Look-Say word guessing worked poorly. But academia and educrats just couldn't give up their word guessing hobby horse. Phonics works better but isn't an end-all-be-all. Showing children that books offer enjoyment is also important, and parents can and should do that. My Mom brought home a stack of books from the library every 2 weeks. I read books aloud to my children for up to an hour or more every evening at bedtime, for years. I took the hint, and my now-adult kids are also readers
An educationally well-governed state does not dictate curricula from on high, but devolves such decisions to local educational agencies, which will do well not to elide writing from "literacy", but will instead plan English language studies based on knowledge of best practices from across the English-speaking and English-learning world, which has led to One World Education Centre's adoption of Oxbridge international education's adaptation of the English National Curriculum for their schools around the world in this subject, combined with our ongoing investment in children's literature (also missing from this article), with knowledge-building derived from the rest of our primary years' curriculum.
Nah, never gonna work. Next thing, folks will be channeling for your Mom, "go outside and play and get some fresh air" (oh, that would be our "wellness" fanatics) or your coach "don't smoke, it ruins your wind" (our no-smoking evangelists) or Mom, again, "eat your vegetables (again with the "wellness" nags). Don`t ya know that history only began in 2000, and all that Old School lore is just so much bunkum?